In response to recent events surrounding State pressure applied to electronic platforms, Risk Division has authorized and implemented a broad warrant canary for all Company sites and assets.
This establishment of warrant canary for Throne Dynamics is solely related to those ongoing external events and is not in response to any interaction or engagement with the Company and its operations.
Telegram CEO Pavel Durov was arrested on August 24th 2024 in France on charges related to use of the messaging platform:
The first preliminary charge against him was for ‘’complicity in managing an online platform to allow illicit transactions by an organized group,’' a crime that can lead to sentences of up to 10 years in prison and 500,000 euro fine, the prosecutor’s office said.
The arrest has brought significant public attention to Telegram use by dissidents and other non-state actors, including criminal individuals, organizations, and institutions. The platform is also used in international and non-international armed conflict:
The geopolitical implications of Durov’s detention cannot be overlooked. Telegram has been a critical tool in several global hotspots, most notably the Ukraine conflict, where it has been used by both military units and civilians for communication and information dissemination. Russia’s immediate response, demanding consular access and criticizing French authorities, underscores the international tensions at play.
Accelerated and oppressive monitoring, suppression, and criminalization of political and cultural speech by nation-states has radically increased:
During the outbreak of Covid-19, freedoms were sharply curtailed with draconian constraints on civil liberties and private enterprise. Governments and advocates largely believed the need to curb the spread of the deadly novel virus, reduce the death toll and prevent public health services from collapse outweighed the importance of preserving individual freedoms.
This raises serious concerns as noted by the United Nations Human Rights Office:
The arrest and charging of Telegram founder Pavel Durov "raises a lot of human rights concerns" says a spokesperson for the UN Human Rights Office Ravina Shamdasani. Russian-born Durov was detained in France on 24 August and charged with violations related to the messaging app. Speaking to reporters at a weekly UN briefing, Shamdasani explains that any restrictions on social media need to be "in line with international human rights standards."
Telegram has subsequently removed its warrant canary from publication:
Telegram has quietly removed language from its FAQ page saying private chats were protected and that “we do not process any requests related to them.” The change comes nearly two weeks after its CEO, Pavel Durov, was arrested in France for allegedly allowing “criminal activity to go on undeterred on the messaging app."
In response, Telegram spokesperson Remi Vaughn says the app’s source code has not changed. “Private chats are still private too – although you could always report a new incoming chat to moderators by using Block > Report. Anyone can check Telegram’s open source code and see there were no changes,” writes Vaughn in a statement shared with The Verge.
Earlier on Thursday evening, Durov issued his first public statement since his arrest, promising to moderate content more on the platform, a noticeable change in tone after the company initially said he had “nothing to hide.”
This follows allegations from Der Spiegel that Telegram was already providing user details to the German Bundeskriminalamt:
Contrary to what has been publicly stated, the operators of the messenger app Telegram have released user data to the Federal Criminal Police Office ( BKA ) in several cases. According to SPIEGEL information, this involved data on suspects in the areas of child abuse and terrorism. When it comes to violations of other crimes, it is still difficult for German investigators to obtain information from Telegram, security circles say.
In recognition and in accordance with these events, a general warrant canary with PGP signature verification has been added to the Terms and Conditions of the Company.
The Company reiterates that the establishment of this warrant canary for Throne Dynamics is solely related to these ongoing external events and is not in response to any interaction or engagement with the Company and its operations in the past, present, or anticipated future.
It is a normal, demanded, and iterative process to maintain freedom of expression and furtherance of human rights in the face of oppressive State action. In these opening months and years of the Third World War it is incumbent upon individuals, organizations, and institutions to be aware of broader changes and predictable efforts by rotted States to maintain control amid collapse.
Implementation of a warrant canary by Throne Dynamics is in keeping with our monitoring of events and directly advances full explication of our duty and fulfillment of our mission.
You bear duty of the State to build, fight, and lead your people and communities in this Age of Militants.
Despair is not acceptable; the black pill must be vomited out!
Members of the public are encouraged to take their complimentary Raw Human Capital and Militant Rank assessments, read the Founder's Substack, and join the Movement.
Individuals who seek immediate and ongoing notification of Company Reports and Risk Division Advisories may also subscribe to our official Telegram channel.
Investors, partners, and clients with questions should reach out to their Relationship Manager.
Throne Dynamics | Risk Division. (n.d.). Www.thronedynamics.com. https://thronedynamics.com/risk-division
Warrant canary. (2020, March 30). Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary
Telegram. (2024). Telegram – a new era of messaging. Telegram. https://telegram.org
Pavel Durov. (2021, October 10). Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Durov
Surk, B., & Charlton, A. (2024, August 29). Telegram CEO Durov faces preliminary charges in France of allowing crime on messaging app. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/france-telegram-pavel-durov-arrest-6e213d227458f330ed16e7fe221a696c
Pari Esfandiari, opinion contributor. (2024, September 4). The arrest of Pavel Durov: A geopolitical power play in the Digital age . The Hill. https://thehill.com/opinion/4861443-telegram-founder-arrested-france
Wikipedia Contributors. (2019, November 1). Sentinel species. Wikipedia; Wikimedia Foundation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentinel_species
Dettmer, J. (2024, September 3). The drift toward unfreedom. POLITICO; POLITICO. https://www.politico.eu/article/democracy-national-security-freedom-telegram-ceo-pavel-durov-arrest-social-media-giants-regulations-emergency-tech-moguls
Elodie LE MAOU. (2024, September 3). Telegram Founder’s Arrest Raises “Human Rights Concerns” Says UN. Barrons.com; Barrons. https://www.barrons.com/news/telegram-founder-s-arrest-raises-human-rights-concerns-says-un-fb42ea3f
United Nations. (2024). Ukraine: Behind the numbers. OHCHR. https://www.ohchr.org/en/ohchr_homepage
Sato, M. (2024, September 6). Telegram changes its tone on moderating private chats after CEO’s arrest. The Verge; The Verge. https://www.theverge.com/2024/9/5/24237254/telegram-pavel-durov-arrest-private-chats-moderation-policy-change
Hoppenstedt, M., & Rosenbach, M. (2022, June 3). Umstrittener Messengerdienst: Telegram hält sich neuerdings an Gesetze, zumindest ein bisschen. Spiegel.de; DER SPIEGEL. https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/telegram-gibt-nutzerdaten-an-das-bundeskriminalamt-a-0e4d3fcb-8081-4b87-b062-db412bbc294b
BKA - Startseite. (2024). Www.bka.de. https://www.bka.de
Pretty Good Privacy. (2020, April 13). Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pretty_Good_Privacy
THRONE DYNAMICS | Head Division | TERMS AND CONDITIONS. (2024). Thronedynamics.com. https://thronedynamics.com/terms-and-conditions/#canary
How The Real Collapse Is Going To Look When It Hits. (n.d.). Www.thronedynamics.com. https://www.thronedynamics.com/reports/how-the-real-collapse-is-going-to-look-when-it-hits
THRONE DYNAMICS | Head Division | MISSION. (n.d.). Www.thronedynamics.com. https://thronedynamics.com/mission
Throne Dynamics | Community Division | Age of Militants. (n.d.). Www.thronedynamics.com. https://thronedynamics.com/age-of-militants
Throne, I. (2024, June 11). Vomit The Black Pill. Substack.com; From the desk of Ivan Throne. https://ivanthrone.substack.com/p/vomit-the-black-pill
RAW HUMAN CAPITAL | Throne Dynamics. (n.d.). Www.rawhumancapital.com. https://rawhumancapital.com
MILITANT RANK | Throne Dynamics. (2024). Militantrank.com. https://militantrank.com
Throne, I. (n.d.). From the desk of Ivan Throne | Substack. Ivanthrone.substack.com. https://ivanthrone.substack.com
THRONE DYNAMICS | Client Division | THE MOVEMENT. (n.d.). Www.thronedynamics.com. https://thronedynamics.com/movement
THRONE DYNAMICS. (n.d.). Telegram. https://t.me/thronedynamics